The pitfalls of craftsmanship

There’s an nteresting – and somewhat depressing – article in the Guardian by Richard Sennett: Out with the old. It casts another light on the problem Douglas Rushkoff identified, mentioned in my recent post.

The consultant embodies the new ideal: flitting from company to company, getting a quick fix on problems, recommending changes, then departing, leaving the consequences for others to sort out, the consultant’s skill is not based on doing one thing well, in one place, with sustained relations with other people.

The person who, by contrast, has the work ethic of a craftsman will dig into problems, acting on the impulse to get something right; this is a psychological strength, but sends a negative social signal – the stubbornness and obsession that fuels craftsmanship slows you down. The craftsman is likely to seem dysfunctional in a culture of innovation and change.

My outtake: something about recognising the value of craftsmanship and seeing a difference between the profoundly new and the merely novel.

Hat tip to Mark Lloyd.

1 thought on “The pitfalls of craftsmanship

  1. IdeaFlow

    More on Douglas Rushkoff

    I still haven’t gotten to Douglas Rushkoff’s Get Back in the Box: Innovation From the Inside Out. But while working with my other blog project, the Corante Marketing Hub, I came across two interesting posts on Rushkoff by Johnnie Moore….

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.