Good and bad Improv

In the midst of a great meeting a couple of days ago with Tim Kitchin and Paul Goodison we shared a grumble about one or two client contacts who were behaving erratically – you know expressing enthusiasm, then changing their minds; half-committing then falling silent. The usual kind of thing.

Yes, it is the usual kind of thing in my experience. And of course the usual kind of thing is for us consultants to grin and bear it. Well today I’m not in a grin-and-bear mode. More just a plain bear mode.

What frustrates me about so many businesses is that they describe themselves in such orderly terms, it’s all strategies and plans and spreadsheets. Yet the day-to-day human reality is sometimes nothing like that. It’s a chaotic cocktail of confused and indirect communication, with oodles of second-guessing of what other people might or might not like.

Businesses sometimes hear about Improv (ie Improvisational Theatre methods) and think it’s completely alien to them. What would we want with all that spontaneity? they seem to say.

Well, I think they’re missing something. The reality, I find, is that they’re doing Improv the whole time, they’re just doing bad Improv. They’re not present to the immediate relationship they’re in – instead, their minds are wandering elsewhere to what some other person might think; they’re constantly fumbling the offers they are made; they frequently fail to give voice to the obvious.

Charles Handy has a nice word to describe what he sees in business today: presenteeism. People showing up with their bodies, but leaving their spirit at home. Gallup surveys consistently show that only around a fifth of workers actually feel engaged in their work. Good Improv exercises quickly get folks to be fully present, an experience that comes as a pleasant surprise to many of them! Bad Improv businesses seem to function only by people ignoring much of what is going on around them.

2 thoughts on “Good and bad Improv

  1. tonygoodson


    The Ourhouse Weblog: Good and bad Improv Nice one John. Yes, businesses play busy and active and decisive, but they’re firefighting and badly in the moment. To me, it’s a no-brainer if something is compelling and good for business and

  2. Paul Goodison

    Great word – presenteeism – I know a few people who fit the criteria.

    Why not throw out a few stories about the kind of ‘exercises’ you can do and what they offer – like the face drawing?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.