Johnnie Moore

In denial…

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

Seth spotted this ad for troubled American Airlines:

and comments

Let’s say you run an airline with a horrible cost structure and you’re facing bankruptcy on an almost daily basis.

Why on earth would you waste money on marketing like this?

Do the folks at American believe that some harried New Yorker is going to choose to fly to Tokyo on the spur of the moment for sushi and because American is the brand that prompted them fly there on American?

Where’s the ROI?

It’s hard for businesses that are in trouble to face the hard truths. So much US airline marketing seems an attempt to put a brave face on things. It’s understandable but I think it treats customers like children who can’t deal with reality.

I can imagine the desire to try and show business as usual and not scare people off. But when two people are in a relationship and are not talking about something blindingly obvious, it’s completely life sapping. Thus American and United both run the risk of being Basil Fawlty, trying far too hard not to mention the war.

There are no miracle cures but I’d recommend some really straight talking. An acknowledgement of the kind of trouble the airline is in. A confirmation of where money can be saved (and this kind of advertising could be on that list); where cuts won’t be made (safety) and the areas where something creative is needed (how to offer efficient customer service without either wasting money or short-changing the customer). A willingness to enter a conversation. A dropping of pretence. A vote of faith in customers that actually would like their airlines to succeed and don’t need a miracle to show some loyalty.

Sadly, I fear that the most likely reason the external conversation is forced and unconvincing is… that the internal ones are forced and unconvincing. And when a company is in denial, I wouldn’t look to an adman for a bit of down home honesty.

Share Post

More Posts

No comment

The value of not always saying something helpful

Beyond writing

Writing stuff down can easily remove us from practical reality and suppress our intuition

Waterfalls and chaos

I linked to this paper on wicked problems the other day and Chris Corrigan commented “there’s a lot in that paper eh?”. Which is true.

Passion branding

Passion brands bring people together based on common interests and excitements. I’m particularly interested in ones created from the bottom up, as opposed to driven by producers concerned mainly with profit.

Medinge Moments

Just back from another extraordinary gathering at Medinge where the community that has produced Beyond Branding meets each summer. I was planning to keep this

Inauthentic marketing: case study

An example of inauthentic direct mail, from Lincoln Financial Group. The elements that eat away at the credibility of the sender and the effect on this reader.

Authenticity: you can’t fake it

Thanks (again) to John Porcaro for linking me to the Customer Evangelists’ blog where I found this: OLD SCHOOL: Ad agency pays teen bloggers to

In praise of um… er….. deeper meaning

Once again, it turns out that what we do naturally has more value than we realise; whereas clever contrivances intended to “improve” our effectiveness often just destroy significance… and make us less well understood! A good lesson for all those presentation trainers and “image consultants” out there!

Follies of ranking

John Porcaro blogsmore evidence of the dangers of running businesses by crude interpretations of numbers… how superficial metrics can cover a rich tapestry of human

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations

Aliveness

Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

Lessons from Star Wars

Sometimes I take the Web for granted and then something like this comes along to remind me what an incredible gift it is… for the sharing of gifts. Stephen Anderson

Johnnie Moore

Bored of marketing?

I’m pretty bored of a lot of marketing and a lot of the conversations about it. I enjoyed Alan Jourdier’s latest post, It Really Is About (Gulp) Leadership. It resonates

Johnnie Moore

David Bowie says IP is in for a bashing

The Church of the Customer blog quotes an NY Times interview with David Bowie who says: I’m fully confident that copyright for instance, will no longer exist in 10 years,

Johnnie Moore

Happiness and stumbling

Browsing the new TED website I was led to this video of a 20 minute talk by Harvard psychologist Dan Gilbert. He explains some fascinating insights into happiness and what