Lists, continued

Chris Corrigan stopped by and added this comment to my complaint about lists.

Why lists don’t work:

1 They gloss over depth.

2 They simplify solutions

3 They inhibit learning

4 They devalue introspection

5 They train users to expect easy answers

6 They provide “solutions” to “problems” rather than analysis for situations.

7 They falsely elevate the list maker to “expert”

8 They are usually offered too earnestly

That’s just so much more eloquent than I could manage thanks Chris.

Needless to say, there is another side to the story and there are lots of contexts in which lists are jolly good things. There were a lot of checklists when I learnt to fly and I’m very much in favour of pilots using them. My point is that there are many contexts in which lists become counter productive for all the reasons Chris states.

3 thoughts on “Lists, continued

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.